Description
According to our City Manager's bi-weekly report, recent Fire Department calls were for:
EMS Calls... 75%
Good Intent (non-malicious) false alarm calls... 11%
(Malicious) False Alarm calls... 4%
Vehicle Accidents... 3%
Service Call (none of the above)... 3%
Fire.. 2%
Non-fire Hazards... 2%
Grass Fire... <1%
Together, emergency fire, non-fire, and rescue activity accounts for less than 10% of all our "fire" department activity, while medical "emergencies" are over 75%.
Yet all of our fire department and equipment are configured for fire fighting operations, so that calls for medical attention (emergency or otherwise, often simply a sick person unable to get to their doctor's office or hospital) are routinely serviced by a fully equipped fire engine and crew, even by (in my neighborhood, at least) a hook-and-ladder truck!.
At the same time our city has contracts with a private contractor for delivery of ambulance and onsite EMS services. Again, in my neighborhood at least, the private ambulance often arrives before or simultaneously with fire service vehicles. Fire personnel stand around watching the EMS personnel service the patient and load them into the ambulance.
I am neither a city services expert, nor a statistician, but I do see that when one of the most expensive city departments is fully equipped and staffed to handle 8-10% of its job responsibilities, while spending 75% or more doing something entirely different, while an entirely different, singularly specialized, profit-making company is paid to do the very same thing, there just may be the possibility of re-structuring to both improve service to the citizen, along with achieving cost savings to the tax payer.
20 Comments
Coco (Registered User)
Theo Bevius (Registered User)
BetterVallejo (Registered User)
Theo Bevius (Registered User)
Theo Bevius (Registered User)
Once again, SCF reminds me that yet another month has gone with no reply -- not even an acknowledgement -- from city government. Why should the busy people at City Hall bother themselves to respond to the comments of a sole citizen?
1 - Because, as my message shows, unchallenged data published by the city itself, and widely disseminated elsewhere, indicates that a very large city agency responsible for spending a large (very large!) fraction of our city's budget is doing so in a manner that grossly ignores actual needs and requirements, and..
2. Because -- so regularly overlooked or ignored by our city's employees, and so-called representatives -- this is a democracy.
Theo Bevius (Registered User)
Theo Bevius (Registered User)
SEECLICKFIX: "Your issue has been outstanding for 121 days. If your issue hasn't been fixed yet, please click below to comment or share. Otherwise, you can close the issue"
Another 30 days without acknowledgement, demonstrating yet again the interest and respect our city employees have for those who pay for their record breaking salaries, benefits, and retirement, and -- in this case -- 90% inappropriately applied budget.
I wonder does anyone have access to comparative data for Taxpayer Satisfaction vis-a-vis Employee Satisfaction for Vallejo?
Artsem (Registered User)
Theo Bevius (Registered User)
Observer (Registered User)
Artsem (Registered User)
Observer (Registered User)
Artsem (Registered User)
Observer (Registered User)
Homeowner (Registered User)
UPDATE: CITY MANAGER'S BI-WEEKLY REPORT, January 11, 2019; The Vallejo Fire Department responded to 1,099 calls for service during the month of December 2018
including:
Building/Structure FIRE 6
Vehicle FIRE 6
Trash/Rubbish FIRE 12
Vegetation FIRE 1
Other FIRE 6
------------------------------------
TOTAL FIRES 31
and
EMS calls 775
31 out of 1099 calls for fire service, 775 (71%) for emergency medical service. And they don't tell us how how many of those Fire Department EMS calls were then duplicated by a call for the perfectly able, city contracted ambulance service. For how many (major and minor) emergency medical calls are we paying for the attendance of a necessary ambulance plus a redundant, fully equipped, and manned fire appliance?
Artsem (Registered User)
Maybe this will help explain, since you will not be receiving a response from the city on this site, guidelines require them to stick to the “canned” responses.
No medical call is “routine.” Most require assessing the patient, obtaining their vital signs, providing oxygen therapy, and moving them, at a minimum. EMS may also need to place an advanced airway, administer drugs intravenously, or monitor cardiac conditions. All of these procedures are completed more efficiently when the appropriate amount of help is on scene. EMS/Ambulance is a crew of 2. Efficient care the goal, and efficient care often is the difference between life and death.
Unfortunately, units have no way of knowing what they will encounter on a call until they arrive. They work in a “what if” and “all risk” business. Responding to the unknown is public safety.
Homeowner (Registered User)
Thanks for the help.
"Unfortunately, units have no way of knowing what they will encounter on a call until they arrive. "
.. and so it's necessary to send an EMS ambulance plus a fully equipped and crewed fire truck just in case of spontaneous combustion of the patient? Really, is that your argument?
In my neighborhood (yours may be different), we regularly see the EMS ambulance arrive simultaneously, or even before the city fire vehicle(s), Sometimes, the fire truck just moves on, other times the truck and crew hang around in the street, while the ambulance crew handle the emergency. Is that what you call "efficient care".
Hey, and while we're on the subject of obsolete emergency management methodology, have you ever looked at the insurance industry data on residential rebuilding costs incurred from direct fire damage relative to the much higher costs of "efficient care" of fire department activity, and resulting water damage?
It's time we put some 21st century science and technology into this 19th century activity.
Artsem (Registered User)
https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/04/11/523025987/why-send-a-firetruck-to-do-an-ambulances-job
Closed Justine (Registered User)
Homeowner (Registered User)